PluginSift

AddToAny Share Buttons vs Social Media Share Buttons & Social… (2026)

Detailed side-by-side comparison of two WordPress plugins, based on real-time data from WordPress.org.

AddToAny Share Buttons

AddToAny Share Buttons

4.7(1,112)

300K+ active installs

Free

Updated 1 week ago
View AddToAny Share Buttons
VS
Social Media Share Buttons & Social…

Social Media Share Buttons & Social…

4.8(5,332)

100K+ active installs

Free

Updated 1 month ago
View Social Media Share Buttons & Social…

Quick Verdict

As of April 2026, Social Media Share Buttons & Social… has a higher user rating (4.8/5 from 5,332 reviews) while AddToAny Share Buttons leads in active installations (300K+ vs 100K+). Both are free WordPress plugins. AddToAny Share Buttons has accumulated 18M+ total downloads while Social Media Share Buttons & Social… has 12M+. Social Media Share Buttons & Social… has a higher support resolution rate (57% vs 50%).

Expert Insight

As of February 2026, AddToAny Share Buttons and Social Media Share Buttons & Social Sharing Icons both serve the social sharing niche but differ significantly in model and focus. AddToAny is fully free with no premium tier, boasts 300,000 active installs (3x more) and an 18-year track record since 2007, with a 4.7/5 rating from 1,111 reviews. Social Media Share Buttons (by Inisev) has 100,000 installs but a higher 4.8/5 rating from 5,332 reviews and a freemium model starting at $19.98 with a 14-day money-back guarantee. AddToAny wins on breadth of free features and WooCommerce/multisite support, while Inisev's plugin offers more visual design variety and animations. AddToAny's support resolution rate is 100% vs 40% for Inisev, making it the stronger choice for reliability. Inisev suits users wanting polished visuals; AddToAny suits those needing a robust free solution.

Analysis by PluginSift editorial team

Who Should Use Which?

Overall Recommendation

AddToAny Share Buttons — with 300,000 active installs, an 18-year track record, 100% support resolution rate, and a fully free feature set including analytics and multisite support, it is the more dependable and versatile choice for most WordPress sites.

Best for Beginners

Social Media Share Buttons & Social Sharing Icons — its 16 ready-made icon designs, floating sticky buttons, and pop-up prompts make it easy to get a visually appealing setup quickly without any coding.

Best for Developers

AddToAny Share Buttons — with template tags, shortcodes, Google Analytics integration, WooCommerce and multisite support, and full open-source transparency, it gives developers far more control at zero cost.

Best for Budget

AddToAny Share Buttons — it is completely free with no premium tier, while Social Media Share Buttons charges $19.98+ for essential features like WhatsApp sharing, mobile-specific settings, and advanced placement.

Best for WooCommerce

AddToAny Share Buttons — it explicitly supports WooCommerce in its free version, whereas WooCommerce compatibility is not confirmed for Social Media Share Buttons in the provided feature data.

Pricing Comparison

AddToAny is entirely free with no premium tier or paid upsell — every feature including WooCommerce integration, analytics tracking, and multisite support is available at no cost. Social Media Share Buttons & Social Sharing Icons follows a freemium model: the free version is limited in networks and design options, while premium starts at $19.98 and unlocks networks like WhatsApp and Snapchat, themed designs, mobile-specific settings, and Pinterest hover icons. A 14-day money-back guarantee and lifetime deal option are available for premium buyers.

Pricing verified as of April 2026

Feature Comparison

AddToAny excels in breadth: free share and follow buttons for dozens of networks including Bluesky, Mastodon, WhatsApp, and LinkedIn, plus Google Analytics integration, URL shortener support, AMP compatibility, and WooCommerce/multisite support. Social Media Share Buttons counters with stronger visual customization — 16 icon designs, animations, mouse-over effects, pop-up prompts, and an email subscription form — but many of these visual perks (themed styles, Pinterest hover icons) are locked behind the $19.98 premium tier.

Compatibility Notes

AddToAny explicitly supports WordPress Multisite, WooCommerce, multilingual setups, and AMP. Social Media Share Buttons confirms WPML and Elementor/Divi page builder compatibility but does not list WooCommerce or multisite support. For complex multi-site or eCommerce deployments, AddToAny is the safer and better-documented choice.

Detailed Comparison

Rating
4.7/5AddToAny Share Buttons
►
Social Media Share Buttons & Social…4.8/5
Total Reviews
1,112AddToAny Share Buttons
►
Social Media Share Buttons & Social…5,332
Active Installs
300K+AddToAny Share Buttons
◄
Social Media Share Buttons & Social…100K+
Total Downloads
18M+AddToAny Share Buttons
◄
Social Media Share Buttons & Social…12M+
Support Resolution
50%AddToAny Share Buttons
►
Social Media Share Buttons & Social…57%
Last Updated
1 week agoAddToAny Share Buttons
◄
Social Media Share Buttons & Social…1 month ago
First Released
2007AddToAny Share Buttons
Social Media Share Buttons & Social…2014
Age
19 yearsAddToAny Share Buttons
Social Media Share Buttons & Social…12 years
WP Requires
4.5+AddToAny Share Buttons
Social Media Share Buttons & Social…3.5+
PHP Requires
5.6+AddToAny Share Buttons
Social Media Share Buttons & Social…false+
Business Model
FreeAddToAny Share Buttons
Social Media Share Buttons & Social…Free
Latest Version
1.8.17AddToAny Share Buttons
Social Media Share Buttons & Social…2.9.7

Rating Breakdown

AddToAny Share Buttons

4.7/5(1,112 reviews)
5
90%
4
3%
3
1%
2
1%
1
4%

Social Media Share Buttons & Social…

4.8/5(5,332 reviews)
5
92%
4
4%
3
1%
2
1%
1
2%

Recent Reviews

AddToAny Share Buttons Reviews

by rocquett

Works great!

All the options I needed are built in, inlcuding easily adding it to the theme template files.

by geoauction

5 Stars!!!

great plugin! works perfect! thanks!!!

by ruslanashev

That’s great!

This is a great plugin that has been working successfully on pointscrowd.com for 3 years now. I like that it works via shortcode, and I have successfully adapted its appearance to my custom theme. Tha

Social Media Share Buttons & Social… Reviews

by theop62

persistent they are.

I will give them a 5 star rating for now, I haven’t even got to setting it up on my site and they have these popups because I deactivated a icon., no big deal, but I usually don’t leave a rating until

by kldp0007

I’ll change after experiencing.

se u soon

by coolhandlukelsk

Will upgrade

Providing 5 stars for making the bulk of the plugin free to the community

Frequently Asked Questions

Is AddToAny Share Buttons or Social Media Share Buttons & Social… more popular?
AddToAny Share Buttons has 300K+ active installations while Social Media Share Buttons & Social… has 100K+. AddToAny Share Buttons is the more widely-used plugin as of April 2026.
Which has better ratings — AddToAny Share Buttons or Social Media Share Buttons & Social…?
AddToAny Share Buttons has a 4.7/5 rating from 1,112 reviews, while Social Media Share Buttons & Social… has a 4.8/5 rating from 5,332 reviews.
Are AddToAny Share Buttons and Social Media Share Buttons & Social… free?
AddToAny Share Buttons is free and Social Media Share Buttons & Social… is free. Both can be downloaded from the WordPress.org plugin directory.
Which plugin has better support — AddToAny Share Buttons or Social Media Share Buttons & Social…?
As of April 2026, AddToAny Share Buttons has a 50% support resolution rate while Social Media Share Buttons & Social… has a 57% rate.
Which plugin is updated more frequently?
AddToAny Share Buttons was last updated 1 week ago and Social Media Share Buttons & Social… was last updated 1 month ago.
Which plugin offers more features for free?
AddToAny offers more features in its free tier — including WooCommerce integration, multisite support, Google Analytics tracking, AMP support, and share counters — all at no cost. Social Media Share Buttons restricts popular networks like WhatsApp and Snapchat, mobile-specific settings, and advanced placement options to its premium tier starting at $19.98.
Which plugin has better long-term support and reliability?
AddToAny has a clear edge in support reliability, with a 100% support thread resolution rate (4 of 4 resolved) versus Social Media Share Buttons' 40% rate (2 of 5 resolved). AddToAny has also been maintained since 2007 — nearly 19 years — and was last updated January 9, 2026, signaling consistent long-term maintenance.
What is the main difference between AddToAny Share Buttons and Social Media Share Buttons & Social Sharing Icons?
The core difference is business model and visual customization. AddToAny is entirely free with no premium upsell, offering broad network support and developer-friendly integrations. Social Media Share Buttons is freemium (premium from $19.98) with 16 icon designs, animations, and pop-up prompts. AddToAny has 3x more active installs (300,000 vs 100,000) but Inisev's plugin has more total ratings (5,332 vs 1,111).

Plugin data sourced from WordPress.org. Comparison and analysis by PluginSift.