Broken Link Checker vs All 404 Redirect to Homepage (2026)
Detailed side-by-side comparison of two WordPress plugins, based on real-time data from WordPress.org.
All 404 Redirect to Homepage
200K+ active installs
Free
Quick Verdict
As of April 2026, All 404 Redirect to Homepage has a higher user rating (4.1/5 from 95 reviews) while Broken Link Checker leads in active installations (500K+ vs 200K+). Both are free WordPress plugins. Broken Link Checker has accumulated 22M+ total downloads while All 404 Redirect to Homepage has 5.9M+. All 404 Redirect to Homepage has a higher support resolution rate (100% vs 71%).
Detailed Comparison
| Metric | Broken Link Checker | All 404 Redirect to Homepage | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rating | 3.8/5 | ► | 4.1/5 |
| Total Reviews | 592 | ◄ | 95 |
| Active Installs | 500K+ | ◄ | 200K+ |
| Total Downloads | 22M+ | ◄ | 5.9M+ |
| Support Resolution | 71% | ► | 100% |
| Last Updated | 3 weeks ago | ◄ | 2 months ago |
| First Released | 2007 | 2014 | |
| Age | 19 years | 12 years | |
| WP Requires | 5.2+ | 4.5+ | |
| PHP Requires | 7.4+ | false+ | |
| Business Model | Free | Free | |
| Latest Version | 2.4.8 | 5.5 |
Rating Breakdown
Broken Link Checker
All 404 Redirect to Homepage
Download Trends
Over the past 30 days, Broken Link Checker averaged approximately 13,894 daily downloads while All 404 Redirect to Homepage averaged 869.
Recent Reviews
Broken Link Checker Reviews
False Positives for Broken Links EVERY TIME
I have used this plugin for years and it’s always been problematic, but now it gives every single link a false positive and then I have to manually check and dismiss each one. If I bulk rescan all of
Thank you
Thank you very much your work developers. I am very grateful for your wok and for your helpful plugin <3. I was migrating from my old CMS to WordPress and on my WordPress Localhost PC I successfully a
Useful by annoyingly inaccurate.
I’ve been using this plugin on 3 of my main sites for several years. It reports too many false positives when it encounters a crawler violation when checking the URLs. I have NEVER been able to connec
All 404 Redirect to Homepage Reviews
Bad Practice
It is bad practice to redirect all 404s to your homepage. The 404 error code exists for a reason: to tell bots and people that the page doesn’t exist. If the page was changed to a new url, you shoul
Fixed My Lost Rankings on WordPress!
IT saved my site after I noticed a lot of 404 errors affecting my rankings. Instead of users landing on broken pages, they now get redirected smoothly to my homepage. Easy to set up, lightweight, and
Too much bloat
And it keeps asking me to buy premium…
More Broken Images Worth Comparing
Top alternatives in the same category as Broken Link Checker and All 404 Redirect to Homepage
Very simply, uses JavaScript to remove broken images from page display.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Broken Link Checker or All 404 Redirect to Homepage more popular?
Which has better ratings — Broken Link Checker or All 404 Redirect to Homepage?
Are Broken Link Checker and All 404 Redirect to Homepage free?
Which plugin has better support — Broken Link Checker or All 404 Redirect to Homepage?
Which plugin is updated more frequently?
Plugin data sourced from WordPress.org. Comparison and analysis by PluginSift.