PluginSift

Site Mailer – SMTP Replacement, Email… vs Emails Catch All (2026)

Detailed side-by-side comparison of two WordPress plugins, based on real-time data from WordPress.org.

Site Mailer – SMTP Replacement, Email…

Site Mailer – SMTP Replacement, Email…

2.2(14)

200K+ active installs

Free

Updated 1 month ago
View Site Mailer – SMTP Replacement, Email…
VS
Emails Catch All

Emails Catch All

5(8)

600 active installs

Free

Updated 4 months ago
View Emails Catch All

Quick Verdict

As of April 2026, Emails Catch All has a higher user rating (5/5 from 8 reviews) while Site Mailer – SMTP Replacement, Email… leads in active installations (200K+ vs 600). Both are free WordPress plugins. Site Mailer – SMTP Replacement, Email… has accumulated 1.8M+ total downloads while Emails Catch All has 16K+.

Detailed Comparison

Rating
2.2/5Site Mailer – SMTP Replacement, Email…
►
Emails Catch All5/5
Total Reviews
14Site Mailer – SMTP Replacement, Email…
◄
Emails Catch All8
Active Installs
200K+Site Mailer – SMTP Replacement, Email…
◄
Emails Catch All600
Total Downloads
1.8M+Site Mailer – SMTP Replacement, Email…
◄
Emails Catch All16K+
Support Resolution
100%Site Mailer – SMTP Replacement, Email…
Emails Catch AllN/A
Last Updated
1 month agoSite Mailer – SMTP Replacement, Email…
◄
Emails Catch All4 months ago
First Released
2024Site Mailer – SMTP Replacement, Email…
Emails Catch All2016
Age
2 yearsSite Mailer – SMTP Replacement, Email…
Emails Catch All10 years
WP Requires
6.6+Site Mailer – SMTP Replacement, Email…
Emails Catch All4.9.8+
PHP Requires
7.4+Site Mailer – SMTP Replacement, Email…
Emails Catch All7.4+
Business Model
FreeSite Mailer – SMTP Replacement, Email…
Emails Catch AllFree
Latest Version
1.4.3Site Mailer – SMTP Replacement, Email…
Emails Catch All3.5.4

Rating Breakdown

Site Mailer – SMTP Replacement, Email…

2.2/5(14 reviews)
5
29%
4
0%
3
0%
2
7%
1
64%

Emails Catch All

5/5(8 reviews)
5
100%
4
0%
3
0%
2
0%
1
0%

Recent Reviews

Site Mailer – SMTP Replacement, Email… Reviews

by petralearnsword

Site Mailer Glitch

I’ve been using Site Mailer for a while now. But I installed it for a new client and the plugin is not working. “Sorry there was a glitch. Try refreshing the page. if that does not resolve the issue t

by Chris

it forces you to set a Reply-To address

I’m unfortunately not satisfied with Site Mailer because it forces you to set a Reply-To address in the plugin settings. There is no option to leave this field empty. For websites that use advanced

by Svensonsan

Installed without my consent

This plugin suddenly appeared on my site without me ever installing it. I can only assume it was pushed through an Elementor update, which is completely unacceptable behavior. Plugins should never

Emails Catch All Reviews

No reviews yet

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Site Mailer – SMTP Replacement, Email… or Emails Catch All more popular?
Site Mailer – SMTP Replacement, Email… has 200K+ active installations while Emails Catch All has 600. Site Mailer – SMTP Replacement, Email… is the more widely-used plugin as of April 2026.
Which has better ratings — Site Mailer – SMTP Replacement, Email… or Emails Catch All?
Site Mailer – SMTP Replacement, Email… has a 2.2/5 rating from 14 reviews, while Emails Catch All has a 5/5 rating from 8 reviews.
Are Site Mailer – SMTP Replacement, Email… and Emails Catch All free?
Site Mailer – SMTP Replacement, Email… is free and Emails Catch All is free. Both can be downloaded from the WordPress.org plugin directory.
Which plugin has better support — Site Mailer – SMTP Replacement, Email… or Emails Catch All?
Support resolution data is not available for all plugins. Check each plugin's WordPress.org support forum for current response quality.
Which plugin is updated more frequently?
Site Mailer – SMTP Replacement, Email… was last updated 1 month ago and Emails Catch All was last updated 4 months ago.

Plugin data sourced from WordPress.org. Comparison and analysis by PluginSift.