My Private Site vs RegistrationMagic – Custom Registration… (2026)
Detailed side-by-side comparison of two WordPress plugins, based on real-time data from WordPress.org.
RegistrationMagic – Custom Registration…
9.0K+ active installs
Free + Premium
Quick Verdict
As of April 2026, My Private Site has a higher user rating (4.5/5 from 80 reviews) and leads in active installations (20K+ vs 9.0K+). Both are free + premium WordPress plugins. My Private Site has accumulated 573K+ total downloads while RegistrationMagic – Custom Registration… has 2.0M+.
Detailed Comparison
| Metric | My Private Site | RegistrationMagic – Custom Registration… | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rating | 4.5/5 | 4.5/5 | |
| Total Reviews | 80 | ► | 456 |
| Active Installs | 20K+ | ◄ | 9.0K+ |
| Total Downloads | 573K+ | ► | 2.0M+ |
| Support Resolution | N/A | 100% | |
| Last Updated | 2 months ago | ► | 4 days ago |
| First Released | 2012 | 2014 | |
| Age | 14 years | 12 years | |
| WP Requires | 4.4+ | 5.2.0+ | |
| PHP Requires | 5.4+ | 7.2+ | |
| Business Model | Free + Premium | Free + Premium | |
| Latest Version | 4.1.0 | 6.0.8.2 |
Rating Breakdown
My Private Site
RegistrationMagic – Custom Registration…
Download Trends
Over the past 30 days, My Private Site averaged approximately 181 daily downloads while RegistrationMagic – Custom Registration… averaged 619.
Recent Reviews
My Private Site Reviews
Great plugin, great support
I have used this plugin along with its companion My Private Site Public Pages for years on multiple websites. I found it very easy to use. Then on using it with a different theme I encountered a glitc
Exceptional Installation and Troubleshooting Service
I had trouble installing this plugin and after reaching out to David for help, he provided multiple days of labor and troubleshooting assistance until the plugin and my site were properly functioning.
Doesn’t work anymore
Used to be a great simple plugin. Now bunch of unneeded extra features and the basic site privacy simply doesn’t work, always returning “robots.txt is still returning 404. Ensure the server routes rob
RegistrationMagic – Custom Registration… Reviews
great support
Thanks to support staff very efficently have solved a strange problem about personal setup
Powerful Plug-in & Quick Support
I tried numerous other plug-ins in an attempt to complete my project, yet all failed me BUT this one.This plug-in will add a robust registration feature to your website. While many other plug-ins only
R
I used the Registration Magic premium plugin for several years until it started giving me problems with the e-commerce module, causing sudden blocks in loading pages and a saturation of requests t
More Registration Worth Comparing
Top alternatives in the same category as My Private Site and RegistrationMagic – Custom Registration…
Powerful user profile plugin to create front-end user registration forms, login & user profile forms. Includes user role editor & content restriction.
The original WordPress membership plugin with content restriction, user login, custom registration fields, user profiles, and more.
The all in one Events Manager for WordPress: create and manage events, sell event tickets online easily. No Coding Required.
WordPress user approval plugin to moderate registrations. Approve or deny real users and prevent fake signups to control who registers on site.
Add beautiful login forms with smooth AJAX login/registration effects, 2FA support, custom redrection options and many more login-related features!
Light weight Front-end login form, User Registration, User Profile and Members Directory plugin.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is My Private Site or RegistrationMagic – Custom Registration… more popular?
Which has better ratings — My Private Site or RegistrationMagic – Custom Registration…?
Are My Private Site and RegistrationMagic – Custom Registration… free?
Which plugin has better support — My Private Site or RegistrationMagic – Custom Registration…?
Which plugin is updated more frequently?
Plugin data sourced from WordPress.org. Comparison and analysis by PluginSift.