Theme My Login vs Smart Protect (2026)
Detailed side-by-side comparison of two WordPress plugins, based on real-time data from WordPress.org.
Quick Verdict
As of April 2026, Theme My Login has a higher user rating (3.7/5 from 460 reviews) and leads in active installations (60K+ vs 10). Both are free WordPress plugins. Theme My Login has accumulated 4.3M+ total downloads while Smart Protect has 1.3K+.
Detailed Comparison
| Metric | Theme My Login | Smart Protect | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rating | 3.7/5 | ◄ | N/A |
| Total Reviews | 460 | ◄ | 0 |
| Active Installs | 60K+ | ◄ | 10 |
| Total Downloads | 4.3M+ | ◄ | 1.3K+ |
| Support Resolution | 0% | N/A | |
| Last Updated | 6 months ago | ◄ | 4 years ago |
| First Released | 2009 | 2021 | |
| Age | 17 years | 5 years | |
| WP Requires | 5.4+ | false+ | |
| PHP Requires | false+ | false+ | |
| Business Model | Free | Free | |
| Latest Version | 7.1.14 | 1.1 |
Rating Breakdown
Theme My Login
Smart Protect
Download Trends
Recent Reviews
Theme My Login Reviews
Straight forward and well documented
I like this plugin, it’s simple to start with and well documented if you need to dive deeper into modifications.
Does exactly what it advertises
Perfect – I just wanted a simple plugin that formatted the registration and login pages. I would like the existing WP login and register pages to redirect to these but not a big deal – and I don’t
Perfect plugin, works like a charm and does what it’s suppose to do.
Magnificent plugin.
Smart Protect Reviews
No reviews yet
More Plugins Worth Comparing
Top alternatives in the same category as Theme My Login and Smart Protect
Password protect WordPress pages and posts by user roles or with multiple passwords; protect your entire website with a single password.
Password Protect Pages, Posts & Content in WordPress
Let your users reset their forgotten passwords from the frontend of your website.
This plugin provides single sign-on via SAML and gives users one-click access to their WordPress accounts from identity providers like OneLogin.
Protect your content with passwords using easy-to-use shortcodes. Supports both global protection and partial content protection.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Theme My Login or Smart Protect more popular?
Which has better ratings — Theme My Login or Smart Protect?
Are Theme My Login and Smart Protect free?
Which plugin has better support — Theme My Login or Smart Protect?
Which plugin is updated more frequently?
Plugin data sourced from WordPress.org. Comparison and analysis by PluginSift.